Most military defeats are analysed after they happen. Maps are redrawn, reports are written, blame is assigned. What is far rarer is discovering a man who predicted the defeat in advance, documented his concerns, and then watched those warnings disappear into bureaucratic silence. That unsettling reality sits at the heart of From Reveille to Retreat, the autobiography of Lieutenant General S. P. P. Thorat, one of India’s most respected military leaders. While the book spans